{ "schema_version": 1, "experiment_date": "2026-11-08", "method": "Compiled minimal LabV1/LabV2 plus OpenZeppelin ERC1967Proxy/UUPSUpgradeable 5.4.0; runCall in isolated EthereumJS Shanghai memory state. Not signed transactions, RPC, a real-chain deployment, wallet operation, audit or safety assessment.", "environment": { "node": "v20.20.2", "solc": "0.8.30+commit.73712a01.Emscripten.clang", "openzeppelin": "5.4.0", "ethereumjs_vm": "8.1.1", "hardfork": "Shanghai" }, "implementation_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc", "source_sha256": "cb1ec434703b0f4c9769b20b2afe512f2ab0edc02135bef1b453312a8efacb33", "package_lock_sha256": "703935e46f8fa3e4d58f83c74314d36f1c4f99815ff52d2771849755d33e66f4", "import_sha256": { "@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/ERC1967/ERC1967Proxy.sol": "a06fe97082355529c1da9076ea6c4518875ca9fdb1a4fa1e194c35cff21b29a1", "@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/utils/UUPSUpgradeable.sol": "dc5dbb1675e3ca321b482eb6665b00a3b876f2119da1f0add8ef172a63eba2e1", "@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/Proxy.sol": "5f5081378d4bc82b814b0d64990b7f7b9c69697593b73a3341f4a269940ba540", "@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/ERC1967/ERC1967Utils.sol": "58c5b19893bf3d7f9e1aa0edc5b908b915eb7af4381800deb425a6e5331f4432", "@openzeppelin/contracts/interfaces/draft-IERC1822.sol": "73653312bc2eda0ec231553a5295242eaef2d4f46a023532d45fe76cbd0f565f", "@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/beacon/IBeacon.sol": "c1c9726bbb0ec4c540c7c98059dcded69a8586b46c168036672381033ee76239", "@openzeppelin/contracts/interfaces/IERC1967.sol": "c4e901318ab6d4963582c62c62ce988a34c68dbae71846b67decacde79e9a317", "@openzeppelin/contracts/utils/Address.sol": "f1a9255dbc40cf9ae7c786abed3b022691a9d24bca0c7f05dc60e63421d405ab", "@openzeppelin/contracts/utils/StorageSlot.sol": "75704538dcb223239280c6726d9a31cf769a7816718517c997fc7d63bdb70778", "@openzeppelin/contracts/utils/Errors.sol": "0704b9d6c032cca8512a3bc3f30f49f86f1f03102d2896a3d23e794b82efea66" }, "solidity_source": "// SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT\npragma solidity ^0.8.20;\nimport {ERC1967Proxy} from \"@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/ERC1967/ERC1967Proxy.sol\";\nimport {UUPSUpgradeable} from \"@openzeppelin/contracts/proxy/utils/UUPSUpgradeable.sol\";\n// Minimal experiment only: immutable lab caller, no assets or application storage.\n// This is not a production contract or an audit reference implementation.\ncontract LabV1 is UUPSUpgradeable {\n address private immutable LAB_OWNER = msg.sender;\n function revision() public pure virtual returns(uint256) { return 1; }\n function _authorizeUpgrade(address) internal view override { require(msg.sender == LAB_OWNER, \"lab owner only\"); }\n}\ncontract LabV2 is LabV1 {\n function revision() public pure override returns(uint256) { return 2; }\n}\n", "states": [ { "label": "initial V1", "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x8f7a45ebde059392e46a46dcc14ab24681a961ea", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x7b0e069eddfce9cbbbcb30d4e051fbe4f7bd4623dd0d406fde865a5bf4c2a1ce", "revision_via_proxy": "1" }, { "label": "outsider upgrade rejected", "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x8f7a45ebde059392e46a46dcc14ab24681a961ea", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x7b0e069eddfce9cbbbcb30d4e051fbe4f7bd4623dd0d406fde865a5bf4c2a1ce", "revision_via_proxy": "1" }, { "label": "lab owner upgrade to V2", "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x6b07eae09874d64b96547c891449166fffd371dafcc2c1978c0df5da893ee44d", "revision_via_proxy": "2" }, { "label": "non-contract target rejected", "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x6b07eae09874d64b96547c891449166fffd371dafcc2c1978c0df5da893ee44d", "revision_via_proxy": "2" } ], "actions": [ { "label": "outsider upgrade rejected", "caller": "0x2222222222222222222222222222222222222222", "requested_implementation": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "success": false, "error": "Error", "events": [], "before": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x8f7a45ebde059392e46a46dcc14ab24681a961ea", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x7b0e069eddfce9cbbbcb30d4e051fbe4f7bd4623dd0d406fde865a5bf4c2a1ce", "revision_via_proxy": "1" }, "after": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x8f7a45ebde059392e46a46dcc14ab24681a961ea", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x7b0e069eddfce9cbbbcb30d4e051fbe4f7bd4623dd0d406fde865a5bf4c2a1ce", "revision_via_proxy": "1" } }, { "label": "lab owner upgrade to V2", "caller": "0x1111111111111111111111111111111111111111", "requested_implementation": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "success": true, "error": null, "events": [ "Upgraded" ], "before": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x8f7a45ebde059392e46a46dcc14ab24681a961ea", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x7b0e069eddfce9cbbbcb30d4e051fbe4f7bd4623dd0d406fde865a5bf4c2a1ce", "revision_via_proxy": "1" }, "after": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x6b07eae09874d64b96547c891449166fffd371dafcc2c1978c0df5da893ee44d", "revision_via_proxy": "2" } }, { "label": "non-contract target rejected", "caller": "0x1111111111111111111111111111111111111111", "requested_implementation": "0x2222222222222222222222222222222222222222", "success": false, "error": "undecoded", "events": [], "before": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x6b07eae09874d64b96547c891449166fffd371dafcc2c1978c0df5da893ee44d", "revision_via_proxy": "2" }, "after": { "proxy_address": "0x39c2540cc64c8562269200ee459dc2853aab9d87", "proxy_runtime_keccak256": "0xae78f18957cbf671cf06e8cddd951b161107633cae248e9076992f2a8d4cfdc3", "implementation_address": "0x15452ec016c4dc8c549e7fe6ff4b26324ea8b7a4", "implementation_runtime_keccak256": "0x6b07eae09874d64b96547c891449166fffd371dafcc2c1978c0df5da893ee44d", "revision_via_proxy": "2" } } ], "direct_implementation_control": { "success": false, "error": "UUPSUnauthorizedCallContext" }, "findings": { "same_proxy_address": true, "same_proxy_runtime_code": true, "different_implementation_address": true, "different_implementation_runtime_code": true, "different_revision_result": true, "unauthorized_and_invalid_target_preserve_state": true }, "limits": [ "No audit report or deployed protocol was authenticated. The first implementation is a comparison reference,not an audited contract.", "Only this minimal immutable-owner UUPS wrapper/version was exercised. No storage migration,initializer,beacon,transparent proxy,multisig,timelock,oracle,bridge or vulnerability assessment.", "The public documentation and local selected source explain delegation. Same proxy address/code cannot alone establish implementation identity or security.", "Addresses and balances are isolated fictitious test accounts;no keys,real holdings,fees or network used." ] }